No Post Here
I'm actually contemplating going to see Twilight. I've never read the books, mind, though they sound hilariously bad. But it seems like going to see hilariously bad in a movie would be even better.
Sparkly vampires, after all.
I wonder about all the folks I've read who keep going on about how unhealthy the entire thing will be for young female readers. And to be fair, in one sense, I agree. At the very least, the excerpts, recaps, and summaries I've seen sound wretched.
At the same time, I grew up on soap operas and Sweet Valley High and some truly wretched shoujo manga. Not to mention, my mother's romance novels. Unhealthy, horrifying fantasy relationships with terrible role models are hardly new for young girls after all. I do think there are unhealthy after effects, but I don't think it's going to bring down an entire generation of young girls.
Then again, I haven't read it, so maybe it will.
I think the most fun part of it is seeing the actor playing Edward rag on his own character in interviews though. I mean, yeah, it's unprofessional, but he's also playing a sparkly emo vampire, so I think possibly one has to cut him some slack. It's still hilarious though.
Sparkly vampires, after all.
I wonder about all the folks I've read who keep going on about how unhealthy the entire thing will be for young female readers. And to be fair, in one sense, I agree. At the very least, the excerpts, recaps, and summaries I've seen sound wretched.
At the same time, I grew up on soap operas and Sweet Valley High and some truly wretched shoujo manga. Not to mention, my mother's romance novels. Unhealthy, horrifying fantasy relationships with terrible role models are hardly new for young girls after all. I do think there are unhealthy after effects, but I don't think it's going to bring down an entire generation of young girls.
Then again, I haven't read it, so maybe it will.
I think the most fun part of it is seeing the actor playing Edward rag on his own character in interviews though. I mean, yeah, it's unprofessional, but he's also playing a sparkly emo vampire, so I think possibly one has to cut him some slack. It's still hilarious though.
4 Comments:
At November 25, 2008 3:38 PM, Anonymous said…
All the relationships I read as a teen that I thought were "romantic" ended up being borderline abusive, in retrospect. Sure, it took me another thirteen years to figure out what made a healthy relationship (and a couple years after that to be sure I didn't have one), but I'm fairly certain that the characters from books only played a small role in that.
At November 25, 2008 4:27 PM, LurkerWithout said…
Man I wish I could get paid 10 million and a percentage of future franchise profits to rag on a stupid character. Good for him...
There is no appeal for me in this actual series, but reading people analyze it and mock it can be good. Like here...
At November 25, 2008 6:28 PM, Diabolu Frank said…
"But I’ll grant this: The audience for the movie — bookish teenage girls in puffy sweaters, hoodies, and horn-rimmed glasses — isn’t nearly as obnoxious as I thought they’d be... I realized that most of these teenage girls didn’t take Twilight seriously. They knew it was trashy. They expected the movie to be bad. They weren’t hopelessly in love with the idea of Edward Cullen. They didn’t want to be Isabella Swan. And during the film, they laughed in all the inappropriate places. It dawned on me, in fact, that for a lot of 16-year-old girls, Twilight is their Snakes on a Plane, and Edward Cullen is their Sam Jackson..."
At November 26, 2008 8:43 AM, SallyP said…
Due to the importunings of her friends, my seventeen year old daughter has started reading these books. Since she breaks into howls of laughter and indignation at frequent intervals, I'm assuming that she isn't taking them seriously.
But then she has a crush on Blue Beetle, so I know I raised her right.
Post a Comment
<< Home